, ,

Writing Aesthetic judgements

I can find out how we evolved and why we like art /what we have evolved to find appealing in sensory input, and so can predict peoples tastes in aesthetic judgments, but there is no way I can independently verify that this or any other value judgement is objectively more valid than any other aesthetic judgement. I cannot do this without a god who sets up objective truth in relation to values. The best I can do is arbitrarily set certain patterns, those based most closely on our evolutionary taste, as some sort of ultimate standard for aesthetic judgements, but in doing so I commit the naturalistic fallacy.